Oprah’s Big Give is a Big Disappointment
I finally caught up on my TiVo recordings over the weekend. I watch exactly two television shows now, Lost and CSI. With Lost now going on an extended break, and CSI still gearing up for new episodes, I decided to record some new shows and give them a try. Oprah’s Big Give seemed to be a show I would like based on its premise of giving away money for good causes. It looked to me to be sort of a reality show for Secret Santas.
The first two episodes were about what I expected, but as the stakes were raised and the dollar amounts increased, I became more disappointed with each new show. In the March 23 airing contestants were asked to give away $100,000 in twenty-four hours. The stipulations were you could not give away more than $500 to any one person, or $10,000 at any one location, and you could not simply give away cash.
I was surprised when none of the contestants visited local churches, hospitals or social services offices. These seemed like obvious places to look for people who are hurting, emotionally, physically and/or financially. Most churches have a long list for their benevolence funds, and not all of them are requests for cash money. Many families need help making a car payment, or getting their mortgage caught up just to get back on track. Others may be recovering from a serious illness and are buried in medical bills, or have experienced a disaster such as a house fire or flood and have lost all of their belongings.
Many municipalities are closing city pools and recreational facilities because of a lack of funding and dilapidated equipment. I can just imagine a local Boys or Girls Clubs in Miami would have loved to have received a new basketball goal, or other updated recreational equipment for their facilities. Orphanages are frequently in need of linens and meal supplies to care for young people in their charge. Soup kitchens and shelters struggle to keep staples such as flour, bread, meats and rice in stock. There is no shortage of stories of victims of Hurricane Andrew still living in homes in need of repair, fifteen years after the hurricane blew through Miami. $10,000 would have gone a long way at each of these places.
Instead, some contestants bought groceries for random shoppers, gave away flowers at an intersection ($2,000 worth), and donated pet food and supplies to an animal shelter. These were all noble deeds, but I thought the name of this game was Big Give! These contestants were guilty of thinking small.
I was once part of a corporate initiative to implement a process improvement plan throughout the company. Our trainer had us perform an exercise in the very beginning of the 6-week training course called “think BIG.” Basically, each team was given an idea and told to expound on it as many times as we could in ten minutes. My group received the task, “Start a youth sports program – your existing budget is $0.00.” We started frantically throwing out ideas and capturing them on a worksheet. Separating each line on the worksheet were the words, “think BIGGER!”
After completing ten or eleven lines we had a strategy to start a youth football league sponsored by area businesses and local sports teams. A new stadium would be built using a combination of public and private, corporate-sponsored funds. Concession sales and banner advertisements lining the playing fields would pay for ongoing maintenance. Not bad for ten minutes of brainstorming. However, if the words “think BIGGER” had not appeared under each idea we might have stopped with “sell Krispy Kreme donuts to raise some money.”
Most people stop thinking big somewhere along the way. We all settle into our lives and outgrow those big dreams we had as a kid. I’d encourage anyone reading this to “think BIGGER” when imagining what we could do collectively to help other people. It’s easy to sit in my living room and play armchair quarterback, but I would like to think if I had a chance to give away $100,000 to people in need I could find more worthy recipients.
Image Credit: Daily News


Monday: Cooking Classes. What kid doesn’t enjoy cooking things from scratch? Spend the weekend brainstorming some ideas and gathering recipes and ingredients. Pick up some used aprons and let the kids decorate them with decorative glue and bedazzles (my daughter claims these are fun). If you really want to impress us frugal dads bake a goodie or two from our favorites list and surprise us when we get home from work.
Tuesday: Matinée Movie Day. Time to get in your pajamas, drag out the sleeping bags and hunt down your favorite movie. If you need a broader selection of movies, check out your local library. Many libraries have a great collection of classics, and a few newer releases as well. Our family loves to gather around a movie on Friday nights with some homemade popcorn. It is even more fun in the middle of a weekday! If you decide to hit the movie theaters, call around first. Many theater chains offer $1 movie matinées when the kids are out of school.
Wednesday: Giant Puzzle Day. When I was in elementary school I had to have my leg in a cast for several weeks. I rode the bus home and my grandmother met me at our house to help with a
Thursday: Make a “Mini-Me.” Our school’s girl scout troop did this around the first of the school year, and I thought it was so much fun we are planning to duplicate it over spring break. The only supplies you will need to buy is a small roll of butcher paper (unless you just happen to have some at home). Check discount/outlet paper stores or party supply stores for the paper. For younger kids you may be able to substitute a piece of poster board, or large construction paper. Round up all the crayons, pencils and markers in the house. Roll out the butcher paper and have each child lay down on directly on the paper. Take care not to slide around too much or you will wrinkle the paper. Have a parent, or a brother or sister, trace all the way around the child to create a complete outline – head to toe. Next, using crayons and markers try to decorate your “mini-me” drawing with matching clothes and cut out your finished product. Tape it to the back of your kids door, or on a closet door as a fun reminder. The drawing also serves as a measuring stick to compare your child’s height over time.
Friday: Pretend You are a Tourist (in your own town). It is always amazing how much you can find to do if you just look in your own backyard. Sure, it’s fun to load up the SUV and drive a couple hundred miles to put distance between you and the distractions of home. However, if you are trying to
Saturday: Put the Kids on Commission. After being inside all week Saturday mornings are a great time to teach your kids the value of a day’s work (or a half-day). I don’t believe in allowances, so my kids are on commission. If they work, they get paid. If they don’t work, they don’t get paid. I know, what a concept. Getting the same allowance every week whether or not you do anything to earn it sounds too much like welfare to me, and I don’t want my kids expecting that every week. Find some safe, age-appropriate chores for the kids to do around the house such as raking leaves, watering plants, dusting furniture, vacuuming, or washing the family vehicle. Teenagers can do things like mow the lawn or help with landscaping chores such as mulching flower beds or putting down new sod. Schedule these kinds of projects around a spring break and make it a family affair. You’ll get some extra help, and your kids will earn a little pocket money.
I returned home to test out the new toilet auger when some new evidence was introduced. My son confessed to Mrs. Frugal that he had thrown a toy “down the potty.” Hoping it would be a small toy that would eventually pass, we asked which one he threw in the toilet. He replied, “Harold the Helicopter.” Fans of Thomas the Train will recognize Harold as the helicopter who buzzes around the Island of Sodor. My main concern was that Harold’s blades would snag on the toilet’s exit and create a messy backup. Then again, this would be an ideal situation as opposed to it snagging in the main drain several feet below the house.
The following is part of Frugal Dad’s weekly series, “



